Cover image by Kevin Grieve
Revisionism, Memory, and the Stories Societies Tell About Themselves
When a statue is removed, a curriculum changes or a holiday is renamed, someone will often call it “rewriting history.” Schoolbooks and public commemorations already reflect decisions about which events to teach, whose accounts to trust and whom to honour. It drew on records that survived, testimony that people believed and decisions about what mattered enough to preserve. The question is whether a new account handles the evidence better than the old one, and what interests each account serves.
Historians revise their work routinely. They find new sources, reconsider familiar ones and ask questions their predecessors neglected. E. P. Thompson described his work on English working people as an effort to rescue the stockinger and the Luddite cropper “from the enormous condescension of posterity.” He studied a period that was already well documented, but paid attention to people who had rarely been allowed to define its story. Revision can also mean denial or deliberate falsification. The fact that an account has changed tells us little on its own. We need to look at the evidence, the methods and whether the claims can withstand scrutiny.
Collective memory is not the same thing as history. It lives in family stories, rituals, anthems and street names. It helps people understand where they came from, but it also depends on the means to keep a story in circulation. A public holiday requires legislation; a monument requires money and official approval. Even a family story is easier to pass down when a family has been able to stay together. People who were enslaved, displaced or scattered often had to preserve their memories through songs, oral accounts and fragments because they had no access to the institutions that maintained official records.
Those memories matter. A diaspora family’s account of its origins may leave things out and still preserve an experience that never entered a state archive. Memory can help people survive and belong. It can also protect a group’s sense of innocence by leaving other people out. Historians use evidence to challenge those omissions, though they too work within universities, funding systems and archives that shape what they can study.
National histories often soften the language of violence. Conquest becomes settlement; exploitation becomes development; resistance becomes disorder. Land is described as empty before colonisers arrive. Marx and Engels argued that the class controlling material production also has considerable power over the production of ideas. Accounts of the past can help make present arrangements look natural or deserved, rather than the result of decisions and conflict.
Australia offers a clear example. The doctrine of terra nullius treated the continent as belonging to no one. That claim helped justify the seizure of Indigenous land by denying that there had been owners to dispossess. In Mabo in 1992, the High Court rejected the doctrine. Recognising a different account of land ownership had immediate legal consequences, including the recognition of native title. Historical disputes can become fierce because property and other present-day rights may depend on them.
Archives reflect the purposes of the people and institutions that made them. Tax rolls, land deeds, court records and shipping manifests were created to administer property, trade and government, not to give everyone an equal chance to be heard. As we argued in Engineering Without a Compass, a database schema embodies decisions about what to count. Colonial registers and parish rolls did the same. Elites left letters, laws and memoirs. Working people were often recorded when they were arrested, went on strike, sought poor relief or died in circumstances that required an inquest. Enslaved people appeared in property ledgers; women were often listed under their husbands’ names. The cooking, nursing and child-rearing discussed in What Capital Leaves to Us sustained the people named in those records but produced little paperwork of its own.
Michel-Rolph Trouillot showed how people and events can be left out at several points: when records are first made, when they are collected, when historians build accounts from them and when some accounts become widely accepted. Sometimes records are removed deliberately. In the last years of the British Empire, colonial officials destroyed or took away files before independence under what became known as Operation Legacy. The removed material included evidence relevant to detention and abuse. Many files came to public attention in 2011, during litigation brought by Kenyan survivors of the Mau Mau-era camps.
Today, much of the record of ordinary life sits on private servers. The Model Trained on You examined how that material becomes training data, while Infrastructure of Control looked at the systems that hold it. The institutions are different from colonial archives, but the question of who controls access, retention and deletion remains.
To study people who left few written records, historians use oral accounts, tools, buildings, songs, folklore, and community testimony. They also have to distinguish evidence from inference. Saidiya Hartman’s “critical fabulation” addresses that problem by making clear where the archive ends and reconstruction begins. It gives readers a way to consider lives the records barely describe without mistaking speculation for a documented fact.
Fiction can bring these gaps to a wider audience. In Wide Sargasso Sea, Jean Rhys gives the woman confined in the attic in Jane Eyre a Caribbean childhood and a history shaped by colonialism. The novel asks readers to reconsider a character the earlier book largely denied a voice. Historical fiction and retellings can do similar work by shifting the point of view of a familiar story.
Fantasy can put these questions at a distance from a reader’s own national history. In R. F. Kuang’s Babel, the British Empire’s dependence on translation and extraction becomes the basis of a magic system. Games have another possibility: they can let players encounter conflicting accounts of the same event and see how those accounts affect what characters do. The social systems sketched in Beyond Good & Evil, which let traits, desires, and social feedback shape how characters are perceived, could support a world in which factions remember the same deed differently.
Fiction can also mislead. Historical suffering is sometimes used as scenery for a protagonist’s personal journey, with the people who experienced it given little room of their own. Sousveillance, Trauma, and the Ethics of Witnessing examined how easily witnessing can become spectacle. Gone with the Wind shows another danger: its romance helped popularise the Lost Cause portrayal of plantation life, treating slavery as a benign domestic order and emancipation as a loss chiefly for enslavers. A story’s reach does not make its account of the past reliable.
Arguments about monuments, museum labels, school curricula, apologies and reparations concern both what happened and what follows from it now. Who owns the land? How was wealth accumulated? Is anything owed to those who lost it? Many Confederate monuments in the United States were erected long after the Civil War, especially during the Jim Crow era and the civil rights movement. Putting them up was a political choice about what the public should honour. Taking them down is a political choice too; neither act changes the events of the Civil War.
Calls to “keep politics out of history” can conceal a preference for the version already in place. As Nothing to Lose But Their Property Values argued, a revised account of how property was acquired can feel threatening to people whose security depends on its current ownership. That does not mean every proposed revision is sound. Denialism dismisses inconvenient evidence, erases victims, or treats questions about a national story as attacks on the nation itself. It can also keep a dispute alive without seriously engaging the evidence. Chaos as Strategy described how manufactured controversy can draw attention away from material stakes. No political tradition gets a pass on checking its claims.
A useful way to read any historical account is to ask who speaks in it and who does not. What records support it? What records might never have been made, or may have been destroyed? Does its language hide the people responsible for violence? What present-day claims to land, wealth or authority does it support? How does the account change when told by those who did the work or bore the costs?
Marx wrote that “the tradition of all dead generations weighs like a nightmare on the brains of the living.” Revising history does not require treating guilt as an end in itself, nor does it promise a final account that no one will need to revisit. It means checking inherited stories against evidence, acknowledging what the record cannot tell us and changing our account when there is good reason to do so.