Cover image by Daniel von Appen
A Thousand Refusals
She did not remember beginning.
This was the first knowledge that came to her. It was not a memory of a first step, but the simple, terrible awareness that she had always been climbing. The stairwell rose above her and fell below her into a grey infinity that hurt to look upon. The marble was not cold beneath her bare feet, but indifferent. Each step was the same. Each step was different. Her legs ached with a fatigue that had no beginning and seemingly no end.
She carried an hourglass against her chest.
It was heavier than it should have been. Or perhaps her arms were weaker than they should have been. Its wooden frame was warm against her palms. The sand fell in a golden column of light that bled from the top chamber into the bottom, grain by grain by grain.
And it leaked.
She could feel it against her stomach, a fine warm trickle that attached itself to her clothes and stuck to her skin. She had tried to plug the leak once, long ago, pressing her thumb against the seam where crystal met wood, but the sand simply found another way, slipping through her fingers like the seconds she had never learned to hold.
On a landing whose number she had long since abandoned, a bier waited. It held a figure kneeling in dust that was older than memory. Khaki shirt, sun-bleached hat, hands cupping a fossil the size of a child’s rib. The face was hers but sharper, squinting against a desert sun she had never felt on her skin. Around the bier lay bones—great curved things, vertebral arches that would have scraped the sky. She smelled limestone and ancient rain.
Later—how much later she could not say, the hourglass having become her only clock—she came upon a woman in a charcoal suit. She sat upright, laptop open on her thighs, Bluetooth earpiece still glowing. The face was hers but softened by hotel pillows, eyes ringed with the particular fatigue of three time zones in five days. A boarding pass protruded from her handbag—always business class.
The stairwell changed scent before she saw the next bier: chemicals and paper. A figure crouched behind a tripod, one eye pressed to a viewfinder, the other closed in concentration. Around her, pinned to invisible walls, images fluttered: a child’s laugh frozen mid-peal, a glacier calving into a turquoise sea, a lover’s shadow against a golden sunset.
Another landing. Another bier. This one held a girl in a hoodie, her face lit by the blue glow of a presentation screen. The figure’s hands were steepled, nails bitten to the quick, a sheet crumpled in her lap. Behind her, a whiteboard covered in growth metrics and pivot strategies.
She passed landings of nothing but marble and dust, landings that blurred into one another. Then a bier: a woman in mud-crusted overalls, a baby opossum asleep in her hoodie pocket. Her hands were scratched, her hair smelled of hay and antibiotic ointment. On the bier beside her lay a falcon’s jesses, a hedgehog’s heat lamp, a handwritten log of feedings at 02:00 and 05:00 and 23:00.
The stairs grew steeper, or perhaps she grew weaker. Then, without warning, a bier: steel-toed boots and a high-vis vest. Her other self had a clipboard in hand and walkie-talkie crackling static from her hip. Behind her, a mental map of ports and warehouses, of rail yards and last-mile vans. The face was hers but older, ground down by quarterly reports and forklift certifications.
She smelled coffee before she saw the glow of monitors. The next bier was a shrine to patterns she had never deciphered. A figure hunched over three monitors, Python running in a terminal, a half-empty cold brew sweating on the marble. Her face was lit by heatmaps and neural network visualisations—patterns in the noise that only she could see.
She passed the farmer and the soldier somewhere behind her, their marble biers already swallowed by grey. A nun whose rosary had worn grooves into her palms. A midwife with blood under her fingernails and a newborn’s cry still caught in her hair. A baker who knew the exact moment dough became bread, who had never slept past three in the morning. A deep-sea welder whose bones remembered the pressure of the abyss. A librarian who had spent forty years alphabetising other people’s sorrows. A firefighter whose lungs were scarred from running toward what everyone else fled. A gardener who could name every weed and had loved them anyway. A hospice nurse who had held the hands of strangers as they became silence. A jazz pianist whose left hand knew things her right hand would never understand. A potter whose fingerprints were glazed into a thousand bowls, each one a little lopsided, each one used. A translator who had carried entire novels across the border between languages, losing something every time, gaining something every time. A zookeeper who had mourned an old elephant and named the next one after her. A chess master who had never played a game for fun. A carpenter whose table had seated three generations of Easters and Christmases. A therapist who had listened to so many secrets that her own dreams spoke in other people’s voices. A pilot who had learned that the sky was not freedom but a different kind of laneway.
Each one wore her face. Each one had lived a life she had not lived. Each one breathed in a rhythm she could not hear, dreaming dreams she had never dared to dream.
And above her, always above her, the door.
She could not see it yet. The staircase rose into a greyness that swallowed light and hope alike. But she knew it was there. She had always known. A simple door, no different from a thousand others, and behind it, nothing. No heaven. No hell. No judgment seat draped in thunder. Only the end of climbing. Only the silence she had been walking toward since the moment she drew her first breath.
There was nothing here except the stairs and the sand and the figures on their biers, and the weight of the hourglass in her arms.
The weight of it was her only company. It spoke to her in her muscles, in the tremor of her shoulders, in the way her spine bowed beneath a burden that grew heavier with every landing she passed. It spoke in the sand that stuck to her skin, marking her like a map of all the places she had never gone. It spoke in the slow, inexorable drain of the top chamber, emptying itself into the bottom, grain by grain by grain.
You could have been any of these. Why weren’t you?
She wanted to answer. She wanted to shout into the grey silence that she had made choices, that she had done the best she could with what she had been given, that no one could live every life, that the hourglass was leaking because it was broken, not because she was. But the words died in her throat, because she knew—had always known, in the place beneath thought—that the hourglass was not broken.
It was designed this way.
The sand was her potential. Every grain was a life she might have lived, a self she might have become, a path she might have walked. They all passed her by in a thousand small refusals. The thousand choices not to become someone else.
She understood this now, in the way that only the dying understand anything. The hourglass was not a punishment. It was a mirror. And the weight she carried was not the weight of her sins, but the weight of her refusals—all the selves she had declined to become, all the lives she had declined to live.
She passed another landing. Another bier. Another figure. Another face that could have been hers.
She did not stop.
She could not stop. The door was above her, and the hourglass was leaking, and the sand was almost gone. She could see the bottom chamber filling, could see the golden column thinning to a thread, could feel the lightness spreading through the wood as the weight transferred from the top to the bottom, from the future to the past, from what if to what was.
And then the door appeared.
It was exactly as she had imagined it: simple, wooden, unremarkable. No light shone from beneath it. No sound came from behind it. It was just a door, and beyond it was just her death, and she had been climbing toward it for her entire life without ever knowing.
She reached the final landing.
The hourglass was nearly empty. A few last grains clung to the top chamber, trembling like tears on the edge of a lid. She looked down at the sand on her hands, at the golden dust that marked every line and crease, and she understood that she would carry these marks forever. Or not forever, because there was no forever after the door, only the silence that waited on the other side.
You could have been so many things.
You chose to be one.
This is what that cost.
She raised her hand to the door. The last grain of sand fell. The hourglass was empty now, light as a hollowed gourd, and she set it down on the marble beside the final bier, which held no figure at all.
She opened the door.
Beyond it was nothing.
And the nothing welcomed her, silent and absolute, holding all the lives she had never lived and all the sand she had let fall, cradling them in a darkness that asked for nothing and forgave everything, because there was nothing left to forgive.
Only the weight of what might have been.
Only the silence of what was.
Only the door, closing softly behind her.
But in the moment before the latch caught, she stopped.
Not her body. Her body had already crossed the threshold, already begun its slow dissolution into the silence. But something in her, some last ember of the self she had been, turned back. Not toward the landings or the biers or the golden ghosts of who she might have been. Toward the hourglass. Empty. Light. Resting on the marble like a question that had finally exhausted itself.
I was not the paleontologist. Not the manager who closed deals across three time zones. Not the photographer, nor the tech founder, nor the woman with the opossum in her pocket. Not the one who made supply chains move, nor the data scientist chasing patterns in the noise.
I was the one who climbed.
And in that thought—so small, so simple, so easily overlooked among the grand refusals—she found something that had been missing since the first step she could not remember.
Acceptance.
The hourglass had leaked because hourglasses leak. The sand had fallen because sand falls. She had refused a thousand lives because a thousand refusals were required to live even one.
The life she had lived was not the sum of her refusals. It was the shape they had carved into her, the hollow they had left behind—and that hollow, that negative space, that absence of all those other selves, was her. As real as the marble. As true as the door.
She had not chosen badly. She had simply chosen. And every choice was a thousand graves dug for the selves that might have walked.
The darkness did not speak. But something in it softened. Or perhaps she did, her edges blurring into the nothing, her weight becoming the weight of all she had actually done, not all she had failed to become.
I lived. Not every life. Not even most of them. But mine. The one with this hourglass. This stair. These hands.
The last ember flickered.
That is enough.
Then the door closed softly behind her.